Ethereum (ETH) co-founder Vitalik Buterin has said solo validators should be tolerated if they censor blocks in special cases in an Oct. 17 tweet.
Мен "сабыр кыл" дейт элем. Бир нерсени кесүү же агып чыгаруу же социалдык жактан координациялоо башка адамдардын блокторун массалык түрдө кайра түзүү үчүн гана каралышы керек, өзүңүздүн эмнени коюу керектиги жөнүндө туура эмес тандоо.
Башка жооптор ETH коомчулугун адеп-ахлак полициясына айландыруу коркунучу бар
- vitalik.eth (@VitalikButerin) October 17, 2022
Buterin made this statement in response to a hypothetical scenario where a solo validator in a warring country refuses to process a block because it includes transactions that donated funds to the military of the rival country.
According to Buterin, censorship should be tolerated depending on the level of transgression. He added that any other opinion could make the ETH community morality police.
Активдүү курацияны жүргүзгөн валидаторлор таптакыр максат эмес. Бул көбүрөөк жооп кайтаруунун кайсы деңгээли мыйзам бузуунун кайсы деңгээлине ылайыктуу деген суроо.
- vitalik.eth (@VitalikButerin) October 17, 2022
Buterin continued, “slashing or leaking or socially coordinated anything should only be considered for massive reorging of other people’s blocks, not making wrong choices about what to put in your own.”
However, not everyone agrees with this view. Bert талашып- that the validator should be slashed or disincentivized because if a system tolerates network-level censorship for a good reason, it can tolerate it for any reason.
Slashed or otherwise disincentivized. If the system tolerates network level censorship for a “really good” reason, it tolerates censorship for any reason.
— Bert (@BertKellerman) October 16, 2022
The founder of Gnosis, Martin Köppelmann, макулдашылган that censorship should be tolerated in this case. But he is concerned about the MEV-boost censorship, which has now made 52% of all blocks.
Эскерте кетсек, бул конкреттүү сурамжылоодо мен да "чыдамдуу" деп добуш бермекмин. Бирок IMO MEV-күчөтүүнү тез арада жайылтуу катасы болгон жана 1 объекттин мазмунун курациялоо учурда бардык блоктордун 52% таасирин тийгизген кырдаалды алдын алуу үчүн кылдаттык менен жасалышы керек болчу.
— Мартин Коппелманн 🇺🇦 (@koeppelmann) October 17, 2022
In his view, the MEV-boost quick rollout was a mistake and should have been done more diligently. Since the Merge, MEV-boost relays have had more representation on Ethereum as validators outsource block production. Since they are centralized entities, they have to comply with the U.S. Treasury Department’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) сактоо сунуштар.
Meanwhile, the crypto community is divided in its response to the Twitter poll by latetot.eth. 47.4% of the 1,010 votes agreed that the solo validator should be tolerated, while 41.4% said they should be slashed for censoring. 11.2% of the votes believe the solo validator should voluntarily exit.
As of press time, 53% of ETH blocks produced were OFAC-compliant in the last 24 hours. 50% of the blocks were OFAC-compliant on the seven days metrics, according to маалымат from mevwatch.
Source: https://cryptoslate.com/buterin-advocates-for-censorship-tolerance-in-special-cases/